TY - JOUR
T1 - Augmented-reality swim goggles accurately and reliably measure swim performance metrics in recreational swimmers
AU - Eisenhardt, Dan
AU - Kits, Aidan
AU - Madeleine, Pascal
AU - Samani, Afshin
AU - Clarke, David C.
AU - Kristiansen, Mathias Vedsø
N1 - © 2023 Eisenhardt, Kits, Madeleine, Samani, Clarke and Kristiansen.
PY - 2023/6/7
Y1 - 2023/6/7
N2 - Background: Swimmers commonly access performance metrics such as lap splits, distance, and pacing information between work bouts while they rest. Recently, a new category of tracking devices for swimming was introduced with the FORM Smart Swim Goggles (FORM Goggles). The goggles have a built-in see-through display and are capable of tracking and displaying distance, time splits, stroke, and pace metrics in real time using machine learning and augmented reality through a heads-up display. The purpose of this study was to assess the validity and reliability of the FORM Goggles compared with video analysis for stroke type, pool length count, pool length time, stroke rate, and stroke count in recreational swimmers and triathletes. Method: A total of 36 participants performed mixed swimming intervals in a 25-m pool across two identical 900-m swim sessions performed at comparable intensities with 1 week interval. The participants wore FORM Goggles during their swims, which detected the following five swim metrics: stroke type, pool length time, pool length count, stroke count, and stroke rate. Four video cameras were positioned on the pool edges to capture ground truth video footage, which was then manually labeled by three trained individuals. Mean (SD) differences between FORM Goggles and ground truth were calculated for the selected metrics for both sessions. The absolute mean difference and mean absolute percentage error were used to assess the differences of the FORM Goggles relative to ground truth. The test–retest reliability of the goggles was assessed using both relative and absolute reliability metrics. Results: Compared with video analysis, the FORM Goggles identified the correct stroke type at a rate of 99.7% (N = 2,354 pool lengths, p < 0.001), pool length count accuracy of 99.8%, and mean differences (FORM Goggles–ground truth) for pool length time: −0.10 s (1.49); stroke count: −0.63 (1.82); and stroke rate: 0.19 strokes/min (3.23). The test–retest intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC) values between the two test days were 0.793 for pool length time, 0.797 for stroke count, and 0.883 for stroke rate. Overall, for pool length time, the residuals were within ±1.0s for 65.3% of the total pool lengths, for stroke count within ±1 stroke for 62.6% of the total pool lengths, and for stroke rate within ±2 strokes/min for 66.40% of the total pool lengths. Conclusion: The FORM Goggles were found valid and reliable for the tracking of pool length time, pool length count, stroke count, stroke rate, and stroke type during freestyle, backstroke, and breaststroke swimming in recreational swimmers and triathletes when compared with video analysis. This opens perspectives for receiving real-time information on performance metrics during swimming.
AB - Background: Swimmers commonly access performance metrics such as lap splits, distance, and pacing information between work bouts while they rest. Recently, a new category of tracking devices for swimming was introduced with the FORM Smart Swim Goggles (FORM Goggles). The goggles have a built-in see-through display and are capable of tracking and displaying distance, time splits, stroke, and pace metrics in real time using machine learning and augmented reality through a heads-up display. The purpose of this study was to assess the validity and reliability of the FORM Goggles compared with video analysis for stroke type, pool length count, pool length time, stroke rate, and stroke count in recreational swimmers and triathletes. Method: A total of 36 participants performed mixed swimming intervals in a 25-m pool across two identical 900-m swim sessions performed at comparable intensities with 1 week interval. The participants wore FORM Goggles during their swims, which detected the following five swim metrics: stroke type, pool length time, pool length count, stroke count, and stroke rate. Four video cameras were positioned on the pool edges to capture ground truth video footage, which was then manually labeled by three trained individuals. Mean (SD) differences between FORM Goggles and ground truth were calculated for the selected metrics for both sessions. The absolute mean difference and mean absolute percentage error were used to assess the differences of the FORM Goggles relative to ground truth. The test–retest reliability of the goggles was assessed using both relative and absolute reliability metrics. Results: Compared with video analysis, the FORM Goggles identified the correct stroke type at a rate of 99.7% (N = 2,354 pool lengths, p < 0.001), pool length count accuracy of 99.8%, and mean differences (FORM Goggles–ground truth) for pool length time: −0.10 s (1.49); stroke count: −0.63 (1.82); and stroke rate: 0.19 strokes/min (3.23). The test–retest intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC) values between the two test days were 0.793 for pool length time, 0.797 for stroke count, and 0.883 for stroke rate. Overall, for pool length time, the residuals were within ±1.0s for 65.3% of the total pool lengths, for stroke count within ±1 stroke for 62.6% of the total pool lengths, and for stroke rate within ±2 strokes/min for 66.40% of the total pool lengths. Conclusion: The FORM Goggles were found valid and reliable for the tracking of pool length time, pool length count, stroke count, stroke rate, and stroke type during freestyle, backstroke, and breaststroke swimming in recreational swimmers and triathletes when compared with video analysis. This opens perspectives for receiving real-time information on performance metrics during swimming.
KW - real-time visual feedback
KW - swimming
KW - performance metrics
KW - accuracy and reliability
KW - tracking
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85163930103&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.3389/fspor.2023.1188102
DO - 10.3389/fspor.2023.1188102
M3 - Journal article
C2 - 37389272
SN - 2624-9367
VL - 5
JO - Frontiers in Sports and Active Living
JF - Frontiers in Sports and Active Living
M1 - 1188102
ER -