Facebook pages as ’demo versions’ of issue publics

Publikation: Konferencebidrag uden forlag/tidsskriftPaper uden forlag/tidsskriftForskningpeer review

Resumé

In this paper, I examine the use of Facebook pages in a recent controversy that resulted in the non-actualization of the so-called ’payment ring’ to be built around Copenhagen to curb congestion. I argue that if we swap the distinction between public and private interest on which the institutions of representative democracy are founded with a distinction between direct and indirect consequences of action (Dewey 1927), Facebook can be understood as an experimental issue public-generating device. In the payment ring controversy, several Facebook pages became spaces of ’demonstration’ in three senses of the word (Barry 2001). First, Facebook pages became used as a device for opposing the government’s plans to actualize the payment ring object. For this purpose, classic features of protests were adopted, including slogans denouncing the decision-makers, the mobilization of peers, and the attempt to show ’political muscle’ through numbers. Second, these protests also focused on demonstrating harmful indirect consequences of a future payment ring by sharing news stories and other analyses that served to undermine the soundness of the payment ring. Third, these two kinds of demonstrations functioned as ’demoes’ in the sense of provisional and experimental versions of payment ring facts and payment ring publics. I suggest that Facebook’s features of real-time commenting and ’liking’, including the counting and visualization of these practices, underpins demonstrations in this third sense. To understand what is at stake in Facebook practices like these, then, it becomes useful to rethink publics as processes of on-going experimental inquiry into issues (Marres 2007).
OriginalsprogEngelsk
Publikationsdato2014
Antal sider9
StatusUdgivet - 2014
BegivenhedNew Perspectives on the Problem of the Public - University of Westminster, London, Storbritannien
Varighed: 15 maj 201416 maj 2014

Konference

KonferenceNew Perspectives on the Problem of the Public
LokationUniversity of Westminster
LandStorbritannien
ByLondon
Periode15/05/201416/05/2014

Fingerprint

facebook
protest
representative democracy
visualization
mobilization
decision maker
news

Citer dette

Birkbak, A. (2014). Facebook pages as ’demo versions’ of issue publics. Afhandling præsenteret på New Perspectives on the Problem of the Public, London, Storbritannien.
Birkbak, Andreas. / Facebook pages as ’demo versions’ of issue publics. Afhandling præsenteret på New Perspectives on the Problem of the Public, London, Storbritannien.9 s.
@conference{c37c413fd2a7411c9efdac97e8e40eb7,
title = "Facebook pages as ’demo versions’ of issue publics",
abstract = "In this paper, I examine the use of Facebook pages in a recent controversy that resulted in the non-actualization of the so-called ’payment ring’ to be built around Copenhagen to curb congestion. I argue that if we swap the distinction between public and private interest on which the institutions of representative democracy are founded with a distinction between direct and indirect consequences of action (Dewey 1927), Facebook can be understood as an experimental issue public-generating device. In the payment ring controversy, several Facebook pages became spaces of ’demonstration’ in three senses of the word (Barry 2001). First, Facebook pages became used as a device for opposing the government’s plans to actualize the payment ring object. For this purpose, classic features of protests were adopted, including slogans denouncing the decision-makers, the mobilization of peers, and the attempt to show ’political muscle’ through numbers. Second, these protests also focused on demonstrating harmful indirect consequences of a future payment ring by sharing news stories and other analyses that served to undermine the soundness of the payment ring. Third, these two kinds of demonstrations functioned as ’demoes’ in the sense of provisional and experimental versions of payment ring facts and payment ring publics. I suggest that Facebook’s features of real-time commenting and ’liking’, including the counting and visualization of these practices, underpins demonstrations in this third sense. To understand what is at stake in Facebook practices like these, then, it becomes useful to rethink publics as processes of on-going experimental inquiry into issues (Marres 2007).",
author = "Andreas Birkbak",
year = "2014",
language = "English",
note = "null ; Conference date: 15-05-2014 Through 16-05-2014",

}

Birkbak, A 2014, 'Facebook pages as ’demo versions’ of issue publics' Paper fremlagt ved New Perspectives on the Problem of the Public, London, Storbritannien, 15/05/2014 - 16/05/2014, .

Facebook pages as ’demo versions’ of issue publics. / Birkbak, Andreas.

2014. Afhandling præsenteret på New Perspectives on the Problem of the Public, London, Storbritannien.

Publikation: Konferencebidrag uden forlag/tidsskriftPaper uden forlag/tidsskriftForskningpeer review

TY - CONF

T1 - Facebook pages as ’demo versions’ of issue publics

AU - Birkbak, Andreas

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - In this paper, I examine the use of Facebook pages in a recent controversy that resulted in the non-actualization of the so-called ’payment ring’ to be built around Copenhagen to curb congestion. I argue that if we swap the distinction between public and private interest on which the institutions of representative democracy are founded with a distinction between direct and indirect consequences of action (Dewey 1927), Facebook can be understood as an experimental issue public-generating device. In the payment ring controversy, several Facebook pages became spaces of ’demonstration’ in three senses of the word (Barry 2001). First, Facebook pages became used as a device for opposing the government’s plans to actualize the payment ring object. For this purpose, classic features of protests were adopted, including slogans denouncing the decision-makers, the mobilization of peers, and the attempt to show ’political muscle’ through numbers. Second, these protests also focused on demonstrating harmful indirect consequences of a future payment ring by sharing news stories and other analyses that served to undermine the soundness of the payment ring. Third, these two kinds of demonstrations functioned as ’demoes’ in the sense of provisional and experimental versions of payment ring facts and payment ring publics. I suggest that Facebook’s features of real-time commenting and ’liking’, including the counting and visualization of these practices, underpins demonstrations in this third sense. To understand what is at stake in Facebook practices like these, then, it becomes useful to rethink publics as processes of on-going experimental inquiry into issues (Marres 2007).

AB - In this paper, I examine the use of Facebook pages in a recent controversy that resulted in the non-actualization of the so-called ’payment ring’ to be built around Copenhagen to curb congestion. I argue that if we swap the distinction between public and private interest on which the institutions of representative democracy are founded with a distinction between direct and indirect consequences of action (Dewey 1927), Facebook can be understood as an experimental issue public-generating device. In the payment ring controversy, several Facebook pages became spaces of ’demonstration’ in three senses of the word (Barry 2001). First, Facebook pages became used as a device for opposing the government’s plans to actualize the payment ring object. For this purpose, classic features of protests were adopted, including slogans denouncing the decision-makers, the mobilization of peers, and the attempt to show ’political muscle’ through numbers. Second, these protests also focused on demonstrating harmful indirect consequences of a future payment ring by sharing news stories and other analyses that served to undermine the soundness of the payment ring. Third, these two kinds of demonstrations functioned as ’demoes’ in the sense of provisional and experimental versions of payment ring facts and payment ring publics. I suggest that Facebook’s features of real-time commenting and ’liking’, including the counting and visualization of these practices, underpins demonstrations in this third sense. To understand what is at stake in Facebook practices like these, then, it becomes useful to rethink publics as processes of on-going experimental inquiry into issues (Marres 2007).

M3 - Paper without publisher/journal

ER -

Birkbak A. Facebook pages as ’demo versions’ of issue publics. 2014. Afhandling præsenteret på New Perspectives on the Problem of the Public, London, Storbritannien.