Masculinity Ideals in a Contemporary Danish Context

Lotte Bloksgaard, Ann-Dorte Christensen, Sune Qvotrup Jensen, Claus D. Hansen, Morten Kyed, Kent Jacob Nielsen

Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

4 Citationer (Scopus)

Resumé

What are the prevailing masculinity ideals among contemporary Danish men? As
one of the Nordic welfare states, Denmark has for decades focused on gender equality and changes in the gendered division of labour. Research has suggested a shift in masculinity ideals, but processes of change comprise not only changes but also continuities, as well as ambivalences and contradictions. This article investigates how normative masculinity ideals—the most accepted ways of being a man in a certain context—are expressed and negotiated by contemporary Danish men, and how these ideals are related to overall discourses of gender.
The article is based on a mixed methods design, consisting of: (1) a quantitative survey among lower-educated men in two male-dominated occupations, and (2) a qualitative, explorative analysis of data from five focus group interviews with both lower- and higher-educated men. The two occupations in the survey constitute a critical case, based on the argument that if traditional
masculinity ideals are rejected here—among lower-educated men, who are likely to be more supportive of traditional gender ideals than the more highly educated—then Danish men in general are likely to reject traditional masculinity ideals. Both the quantitative and qualitative analyses indicate that traditional patriarchal masculinity ideals are not the most legitimate among the men. They seem to subscribe to more gender equality friendly masculinities, although this picture is not clear-cut as we also see negotiations and variations between the men. Thus, the article concludes that in a Danish context we can identify
authoritative masculinity ideals that do not reproduce patriarchy or support traditional masculinity ideals in an unambiguous way.
OriginalsprogEngelsk
Artikelnummer1
TidsskriftNORA - Nordic Journal of Feminist and Gender Research
Vol/bind23
Udgave nummer3
Sider (fra-til)152-169
ISSN0803-8740
DOI
StatusUdgivet - 10 aug. 2015

Fingerprint

masculinity
gender
equality
occupation
patriarchy
division of labor
ambivalence
Denmark
welfare state
continuity
discourse
interview

Citer dette

@article{ddab10366ba4435babd5de148aaceff0,
title = "Masculinity Ideals in a Contemporary Danish Context",
abstract = "What are the prevailing masculinity ideals among contemporary Danish men? Asone of the Nordic welfare states, Denmark has for decades focused on gender equality and changes in the gendered division of labour. Research has suggested a shift in masculinity ideals, but processes of change comprise not only changes but also continuities, as well as ambivalences and contradictions. This article investigates how normative masculinity ideals—the most accepted ways of being a man in a certain context—are expressed and negotiated by contemporary Danish men, and how these ideals are related to overall discourses of gender.The article is based on a mixed methods design, consisting of: (1) a quantitative survey among lower-educated men in two male-dominated occupations, and (2) a qualitative, explorative analysis of data from five focus group interviews with both lower- and higher-educated men. The two occupations in the survey constitute a critical case, based on the argument that if traditionalmasculinity ideals are rejected here—among lower-educated men, who are likely to be more supportive of traditional gender ideals than the more highly educated—then Danish men in general are likely to reject traditional masculinity ideals. Both the quantitative and qualitative analyses indicate that traditional patriarchal masculinity ideals are not the most legitimate among the men. They seem to subscribe to more gender equality friendly masculinities, although this picture is not clear-cut as we also see negotiations and variations between the men. Thus, the article concludes that in a Danish context we can identifyauthoritative masculinity ideals that do not reproduce patriarchy or support traditional masculinity ideals in an unambiguous way.",
author = "Lotte Bloksgaard and Ann-Dorte Christensen and Jensen, {Sune Qvotrup} and Hansen, {Claus D.} and Morten Kyed and Nielsen, {Kent Jacob}",
year = "2015",
month = "8",
day = "10",
doi = "10.1080/08038740.2015.1046918",
language = "English",
volume = "23",
pages = "152--169",
journal = "NORA - Nordic Journal of Feminist and Gender Research",
issn = "0803-8740",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",
number = "3",

}

Masculinity Ideals in a Contemporary Danish Context. / Bloksgaard, Lotte; Christensen, Ann-Dorte; Jensen, Sune Qvotrup; Hansen, Claus D.; Kyed, Morten; Nielsen, Kent Jacob.

I: NORA - Nordic Journal of Feminist and Gender Research, Bind 23, Nr. 3, 1, 10.08.2015, s. 152-169.

Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Masculinity Ideals in a Contemporary Danish Context

AU - Bloksgaard, Lotte

AU - Christensen, Ann-Dorte

AU - Jensen, Sune Qvotrup

AU - Hansen, Claus D.

AU - Kyed, Morten

AU - Nielsen, Kent Jacob

PY - 2015/8/10

Y1 - 2015/8/10

N2 - What are the prevailing masculinity ideals among contemporary Danish men? Asone of the Nordic welfare states, Denmark has for decades focused on gender equality and changes in the gendered division of labour. Research has suggested a shift in masculinity ideals, but processes of change comprise not only changes but also continuities, as well as ambivalences and contradictions. This article investigates how normative masculinity ideals—the most accepted ways of being a man in a certain context—are expressed and negotiated by contemporary Danish men, and how these ideals are related to overall discourses of gender.The article is based on a mixed methods design, consisting of: (1) a quantitative survey among lower-educated men in two male-dominated occupations, and (2) a qualitative, explorative analysis of data from five focus group interviews with both lower- and higher-educated men. The two occupations in the survey constitute a critical case, based on the argument that if traditionalmasculinity ideals are rejected here—among lower-educated men, who are likely to be more supportive of traditional gender ideals than the more highly educated—then Danish men in general are likely to reject traditional masculinity ideals. Both the quantitative and qualitative analyses indicate that traditional patriarchal masculinity ideals are not the most legitimate among the men. They seem to subscribe to more gender equality friendly masculinities, although this picture is not clear-cut as we also see negotiations and variations between the men. Thus, the article concludes that in a Danish context we can identifyauthoritative masculinity ideals that do not reproduce patriarchy or support traditional masculinity ideals in an unambiguous way.

AB - What are the prevailing masculinity ideals among contemporary Danish men? Asone of the Nordic welfare states, Denmark has for decades focused on gender equality and changes in the gendered division of labour. Research has suggested a shift in masculinity ideals, but processes of change comprise not only changes but also continuities, as well as ambivalences and contradictions. This article investigates how normative masculinity ideals—the most accepted ways of being a man in a certain context—are expressed and negotiated by contemporary Danish men, and how these ideals are related to overall discourses of gender.The article is based on a mixed methods design, consisting of: (1) a quantitative survey among lower-educated men in two male-dominated occupations, and (2) a qualitative, explorative analysis of data from five focus group interviews with both lower- and higher-educated men. The two occupations in the survey constitute a critical case, based on the argument that if traditionalmasculinity ideals are rejected here—among lower-educated men, who are likely to be more supportive of traditional gender ideals than the more highly educated—then Danish men in general are likely to reject traditional masculinity ideals. Both the quantitative and qualitative analyses indicate that traditional patriarchal masculinity ideals are not the most legitimate among the men. They seem to subscribe to more gender equality friendly masculinities, although this picture is not clear-cut as we also see negotiations and variations between the men. Thus, the article concludes that in a Danish context we can identifyauthoritative masculinity ideals that do not reproduce patriarchy or support traditional masculinity ideals in an unambiguous way.

U2 - 10.1080/08038740.2015.1046918

DO - 10.1080/08038740.2015.1046918

M3 - Journal article

VL - 23

SP - 152

EP - 169

JO - NORA - Nordic Journal of Feminist and Gender Research

JF - NORA - Nordic Journal of Feminist and Gender Research

SN - 0803-8740

IS - 3

M1 - 1

ER -