Short-term versus long-term approaches to the development of tourism-related policies

Dianne Dredge

Publikation: Working paperRådgivningpeer review

487 Downloads (Pure)

Resumé

Tourism policy development is an increasingly complex activity involving multiple public sector agencies, industry and community stakeholders and non-government organisations at different scales. This discussion paper examines the implications for tourism of governments adopting short- term versus long-term approaches to the development of tourism related policies and identifies policy considerations to maximize the growth potential of tourism. The key issue is to understand how governments can strengthen their support for tourism growth and development by taking an integrated cross-sector policy approach.

The discussion paper commences by examining the unique character of tourism policyscape and recognises that it involves a wide variety of inter-linked policy sectors that often operate and develop policies in separate policy processes. Little attention is placed on cross-sector policy interactions and interdependencies that affect policy outcomes over the long term.

The discussion paper then examines institutional arrangements for tourism policy, observing that industrial policy approaches have tended to dominate tourism policy. These industrial approaches focus on stimulus measures to increase tourism productivity (i.e. visitors and visitor nights, yield and length of stay), and do not generally take a wider strategic perspective that leverages policy inter-linkages (complementarities and trade-offs) between tourism and other policy sectors.
Tourism policy complementarities emerge when policies in different sectors mutually reinforce each other to collectively produce higher returns than each policy would generate individually. Trade-offs occur when policies produce potentially inconsistent or conflicting outcomes and a strategic trade-off is required to maximise tourism benefits. A long-term approach to tourism policy would leverage policy inter-linkages between tourism and, for example, land use planning, infrastructure policy, environmental management, health and safety policy, and emergency management. This approach does not simply seek short-term outcomes to stabilize, adjust or re- orientate to new tourism market opportunities, but over the long-term, contributes to stronger, more competitive, innovative and resilient destinations.

The discussion paper explores examples of policy inter-linkages between tourism and land use planning, transport and emergency management and takes the position that this long-term approach is about securing the longevity of tourism as an economic and social force by focusing on policy synergies to improve aspects such as destination resilience and competitiveness, environmental sustainability, industry innovation and strategic improvements to productivity.

The discussion paper concludes by identifying policy considerations and potential actions that can assist in leveraging tourism policy inter-linkages.
OriginalsprogEngelsk
Udgivelses stedParis
UdgiverOrganisation for Economic Cooporation and Development, OECD
Antal sider26
DOI
StatusUdgivet - 2015

Fingerprint

Tourism
Tourism policy
Interlinkage
Trade-offs
Land use planning
Destination
Industry
Complementarity
Emergency management
Government
Productivity
Leverage
Interaction
Environmental sustainability
Policy management
Competitiveness
Synergy
Environmental management
Public sector
Interdependencies

Citer dette

Dredge, D. (2015). Short-term versus long-term approaches to the development of tourism-related policies. Paris: Organisation for Economic Cooporation and Development, OECD. https://doi.org/10.1787/5js4vmp5n5r8-en
Dredge, Dianne. / Short-term versus long-term approaches to the development of tourism-related policies. Paris : Organisation for Economic Cooporation and Development, OECD, 2015.
@techreport{f73854c9b70f4cc49c1327a9a246782c,
title = "Short-term versus long-term approaches to the development of tourism-related policies",
abstract = "Tourism policy development is an increasingly complex activity involving multiple public sector agencies, industry and community stakeholders and non-government organisations at different scales. This discussion paper examines the implications for tourism of governments adopting short- term versus long-term approaches to the development of tourism related policies and identifies policy considerations to maximize the growth potential of tourism. The key issue is to understand how governments can strengthen their support for tourism growth and development by taking an integrated cross-sector policy approach.The discussion paper commences by examining the unique character of tourism policyscape and recognises that it involves a wide variety of inter-linked policy sectors that often operate and develop policies in separate policy processes. Little attention is placed on cross-sector policy interactions and interdependencies that affect policy outcomes over the long term.The discussion paper then examines institutional arrangements for tourism policy, observing that industrial policy approaches have tended to dominate tourism policy. These industrial approaches focus on stimulus measures to increase tourism productivity (i.e. visitors and visitor nights, yield and length of stay), and do not generally take a wider strategic perspective that leverages policy inter-linkages (complementarities and trade-offs) between tourism and other policy sectors.Tourism policy complementarities emerge when policies in different sectors mutually reinforce each other to collectively produce higher returns than each policy would generate individually. Trade-offs occur when policies produce potentially inconsistent or conflicting outcomes and a strategic trade-off is required to maximise tourism benefits. A long-term approach to tourism policy would leverage policy inter-linkages between tourism and, for example, land use planning, infrastructure policy, environmental management, health and safety policy, and emergency management. This approach does not simply seek short-term outcomes to stabilize, adjust or re- orientate to new tourism market opportunities, but over the long-term, contributes to stronger, more competitive, innovative and resilient destinations.The discussion paper explores examples of policy inter-linkages between tourism and land use planning, transport and emergency management and takes the position that this long-term approach is about securing the longevity of tourism as an economic and social force by focusing on policy synergies to improve aspects such as destination resilience and competitiveness, environmental sustainability, industry innovation and strategic improvements to productivity.The discussion paper concludes by identifying policy considerations and potential actions that can assist in leveraging tourism policy inter-linkages.",
keywords = "tourism policy, tourism management, policy analysis, policy ecologies",
author = "Dianne Dredge",
note = "This working paper contributed to the OECD Tourism Paper 2015/01 {"}A Review of Effective Policies for Tourism Growth{"}",
year = "2015",
doi = "10.1787/5js4vmp5n5r8-en",
language = "English",
publisher = "Organisation for Economic Cooporation and Development, OECD",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "Organisation for Economic Cooporation and Development, OECD",

}

Dredge, D 2015 'Short-term versus long-term approaches to the development of tourism-related policies' Organisation for Economic Cooporation and Development, OECD, Paris. https://doi.org/10.1787/5js4vmp5n5r8-en

Short-term versus long-term approaches to the development of tourism-related policies. / Dredge, Dianne.

Paris : Organisation for Economic Cooporation and Development, OECD, 2015.

Publikation: Working paperRådgivningpeer review

TY - UNPB

T1 - Short-term versus long-term approaches to the development of tourism-related policies

AU - Dredge, Dianne

N1 - This working paper contributed to the OECD Tourism Paper 2015/01 "A Review of Effective Policies for Tourism Growth"

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - Tourism policy development is an increasingly complex activity involving multiple public sector agencies, industry and community stakeholders and non-government organisations at different scales. This discussion paper examines the implications for tourism of governments adopting short- term versus long-term approaches to the development of tourism related policies and identifies policy considerations to maximize the growth potential of tourism. The key issue is to understand how governments can strengthen their support for tourism growth and development by taking an integrated cross-sector policy approach.The discussion paper commences by examining the unique character of tourism policyscape and recognises that it involves a wide variety of inter-linked policy sectors that often operate and develop policies in separate policy processes. Little attention is placed on cross-sector policy interactions and interdependencies that affect policy outcomes over the long term.The discussion paper then examines institutional arrangements for tourism policy, observing that industrial policy approaches have tended to dominate tourism policy. These industrial approaches focus on stimulus measures to increase tourism productivity (i.e. visitors and visitor nights, yield and length of stay), and do not generally take a wider strategic perspective that leverages policy inter-linkages (complementarities and trade-offs) between tourism and other policy sectors.Tourism policy complementarities emerge when policies in different sectors mutually reinforce each other to collectively produce higher returns than each policy would generate individually. Trade-offs occur when policies produce potentially inconsistent or conflicting outcomes and a strategic trade-off is required to maximise tourism benefits. A long-term approach to tourism policy would leverage policy inter-linkages between tourism and, for example, land use planning, infrastructure policy, environmental management, health and safety policy, and emergency management. This approach does not simply seek short-term outcomes to stabilize, adjust or re- orientate to new tourism market opportunities, but over the long-term, contributes to stronger, more competitive, innovative and resilient destinations.The discussion paper explores examples of policy inter-linkages between tourism and land use planning, transport and emergency management and takes the position that this long-term approach is about securing the longevity of tourism as an economic and social force by focusing on policy synergies to improve aspects such as destination resilience and competitiveness, environmental sustainability, industry innovation and strategic improvements to productivity.The discussion paper concludes by identifying policy considerations and potential actions that can assist in leveraging tourism policy inter-linkages.

AB - Tourism policy development is an increasingly complex activity involving multiple public sector agencies, industry and community stakeholders and non-government organisations at different scales. This discussion paper examines the implications for tourism of governments adopting short- term versus long-term approaches to the development of tourism related policies and identifies policy considerations to maximize the growth potential of tourism. The key issue is to understand how governments can strengthen their support for tourism growth and development by taking an integrated cross-sector policy approach.The discussion paper commences by examining the unique character of tourism policyscape and recognises that it involves a wide variety of inter-linked policy sectors that often operate and develop policies in separate policy processes. Little attention is placed on cross-sector policy interactions and interdependencies that affect policy outcomes over the long term.The discussion paper then examines institutional arrangements for tourism policy, observing that industrial policy approaches have tended to dominate tourism policy. These industrial approaches focus on stimulus measures to increase tourism productivity (i.e. visitors and visitor nights, yield and length of stay), and do not generally take a wider strategic perspective that leverages policy inter-linkages (complementarities and trade-offs) between tourism and other policy sectors.Tourism policy complementarities emerge when policies in different sectors mutually reinforce each other to collectively produce higher returns than each policy would generate individually. Trade-offs occur when policies produce potentially inconsistent or conflicting outcomes and a strategic trade-off is required to maximise tourism benefits. A long-term approach to tourism policy would leverage policy inter-linkages between tourism and, for example, land use planning, infrastructure policy, environmental management, health and safety policy, and emergency management. This approach does not simply seek short-term outcomes to stabilize, adjust or re- orientate to new tourism market opportunities, but over the long-term, contributes to stronger, more competitive, innovative and resilient destinations.The discussion paper explores examples of policy inter-linkages between tourism and land use planning, transport and emergency management and takes the position that this long-term approach is about securing the longevity of tourism as an economic and social force by focusing on policy synergies to improve aspects such as destination resilience and competitiveness, environmental sustainability, industry innovation and strategic improvements to productivity.The discussion paper concludes by identifying policy considerations and potential actions that can assist in leveraging tourism policy inter-linkages.

KW - tourism policy

KW - tourism management

KW - policy analysis

KW - policy ecologies

U2 - 10.1787/5js4vmp5n5r8-en

DO - 10.1787/5js4vmp5n5r8-en

M3 - Working paper

BT - Short-term versus long-term approaches to the development of tourism-related policies

PB - Organisation for Economic Cooporation and Development, OECD

CY - Paris

ER -

Dredge D. Short-term versus long-term approaches to the development of tourism-related policies. Paris: Organisation for Economic Cooporation and Development, OECD. 2015. https://doi.org/10.1787/5js4vmp5n5r8-en