Beyond the dichotomy of figurative and abstract art in hospitals

The potential of visual art as a generator of well-being

Research output: Contribution to book/anthology/report/conference proceedingArticle in proceedingResearchpeer-review

396 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Within the evidence-based design discourse, and deriving particularly from the theory of emotional congruence, abstract art has been indicated as unsuitable for hospitals. As patients may often experience unfamiliarity, vulnerability, stress, unpredictability and uneasiness in hospitals, these negative factors in terms of patients’ well-being are predicted to be detrimentally reinforced by abstract art, but alleviated by particular forms of figurative art. The present paper focuses particularly on this question of the suitability of abstract art in Danish hospital settings and presents findings from two experimental case studies on 98 patients’ well-being in relation to their experience and use of visual art during hospitalization.
The case studies employed a mixed-method approach, including interviews and observations informed by thermal video recording, surveys and psychophysiological experiments.
Six experiential domains are employed to understand the notion of experience of ‘well-being’: Space, Time, Inter-subjectivity, Body, Mood and Personal identity.
The hypothesis that the ambiguity of abstract art leads to stressful effects is not confirmed by the study’s findings. The studies are developed to qualify current guidelines for the application of art, which emphasize a dichotomy between figurative and abstract art. While confirming the positive effects of figurative art, the studies indicate that the ambiguity of meaning in abstract compositions can also facilitate patients’ memories, thoughts and feelings, addressed as experiential domains of well-being.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationARCH17 : 3rd international conference on architecture, research, care and health. Conference Proceedings
EditorsNanet Mathiasen, Anne Kathrine Frandsen
Number of pages15
Volume1
Place of PublicationKøbenhavn
PublisherPolyteknisk Boghandel og Forlag
Publication dateApr 2017
Edition1
Pages105
Chapter120
ISBN (Electronic)978-87-93585-00-3
Publication statusPublished - Apr 2017
Event ARCH17 - The 3rd International Conference on Architecture, Research, Care and Health: 3rd international conference on architecture, research, care and health - Aalborg Universitet, A.C. Meyers Vænge 15, København, Denmark
Duration: 26 Apr 201727 Apr 2017
Conference number: 3
http://www.arch17.aau.dk
http://www.arch17.aau.dk/

Conference

Conference ARCH17 - The 3rd International Conference on Architecture, Research, Care and Health
Number3
LocationAalborg Universitet, A.C. Meyers Vænge 15
CountryDenmark
CityKøbenhavn
Period26/04/201727/04/2017
Internet address

Fingerprint

Well-being
Figurative
Abstract Art
Dichotomy
Figurative Art
Emotion
Art
Mixed Methods
Vulnerability
Congruence
Personal Identity
Mood
Experiment
Intersubjectivity
Hospitalization
Discourse
Unpredictability

Cite this

Nielsen, S. M. L., & Mullins, M. F. (2017). Beyond the dichotomy of figurative and abstract art in hospitals: The potential of visual art as a generator of well-being. In N. Mathiasen, & A. K. Frandsen (Eds.), ARCH17: 3rd international conference on architecture, research, care and health. Conference Proceedings (1 ed., Vol. 1, pp. 105). København: Polyteknisk Boghandel og Forlag.
Nielsen, Stine Maria Louring ; Mullins, Michael Finbarr. / Beyond the dichotomy of figurative and abstract art in hospitals : The potential of visual art as a generator of well-being. ARCH17: 3rd international conference on architecture, research, care and health. Conference Proceedings. editor / Nanet Mathiasen ; Anne Kathrine Frandsen. Vol. 1 1. ed. København : Polyteknisk Boghandel og Forlag, 2017. pp. 105
@inproceedings{76c7c3aba64a4b788e4ae2a73f045654,
title = "Beyond the dichotomy of figurative and abstract art in hospitals: The potential of visual art as a generator of well-being",
abstract = "Within the evidence-based design discourse, and deriving particularly from the theory of emotional congruence, abstract art has been indicated as unsuitable for hospitals. As patients may often experience unfamiliarity, vulnerability, stress, unpredictability and uneasiness in hospitals, these negative factors in terms of patients’ well-being are predicted to be detrimentally reinforced by abstract art, but alleviated by particular forms of figurative art. The present paper focuses particularly on this question of the suitability of abstract art in Danish hospital settings and presents findings from two experimental case studies on 98 patients’ well-being in relation to their experience and use of visual art during hospitalization. The case studies employed a mixed-method approach, including interviews and observations informed by thermal video recording, surveys and psychophysiological experiments. Six experiential domains are employed to understand the notion of experience of ‘well-being’: Space, Time, Inter-subjectivity, Body, Mood and Personal identity. The hypothesis that the ambiguity of abstract art leads to stressful effects is not confirmed by the study’s findings. The studies are developed to qualify current guidelines for the application of art, which emphasize a dichotomy between figurative and abstract art. While confirming the positive effects of figurative art, the studies indicate that the ambiguity of meaning in abstract compositions can also facilitate patients’ memories, thoughts and feelings, addressed as experiential domains of well-being.",
keywords = "health environment, healing arts, well-being, phenomenology, mixed-methods",
author = "Nielsen, {Stine Maria Louring} and Mullins, {Michael Finbarr}",
year = "2017",
month = "4",
language = "English",
volume = "1",
pages = "105",
editor = "Nanet Mathiasen and Frandsen, {Anne Kathrine }",
booktitle = "ARCH17",
publisher = "Polyteknisk Boghandel og Forlag",
edition = "1",

}

Nielsen, SML & Mullins, MF 2017, Beyond the dichotomy of figurative and abstract art in hospitals: The potential of visual art as a generator of well-being. in N Mathiasen & AK Frandsen (eds), ARCH17: 3rd international conference on architecture, research, care and health. Conference Proceedings. 1 edn, vol. 1, Polyteknisk Boghandel og Forlag, København, pp. 105, ARCH17 - The 3rd International Conference on Architecture, Research, Care and Health, København, Denmark, 26/04/2017.

Beyond the dichotomy of figurative and abstract art in hospitals : The potential of visual art as a generator of well-being. / Nielsen, Stine Maria Louring; Mullins, Michael Finbarr.

ARCH17: 3rd international conference on architecture, research, care and health. Conference Proceedings. ed. / Nanet Mathiasen; Anne Kathrine Frandsen. Vol. 1 1. ed. København : Polyteknisk Boghandel og Forlag, 2017. p. 105.

Research output: Contribution to book/anthology/report/conference proceedingArticle in proceedingResearchpeer-review

TY - GEN

T1 - Beyond the dichotomy of figurative and abstract art in hospitals

T2 - The potential of visual art as a generator of well-being

AU - Nielsen, Stine Maria Louring

AU - Mullins, Michael Finbarr

PY - 2017/4

Y1 - 2017/4

N2 - Within the evidence-based design discourse, and deriving particularly from the theory of emotional congruence, abstract art has been indicated as unsuitable for hospitals. As patients may often experience unfamiliarity, vulnerability, stress, unpredictability and uneasiness in hospitals, these negative factors in terms of patients’ well-being are predicted to be detrimentally reinforced by abstract art, but alleviated by particular forms of figurative art. The present paper focuses particularly on this question of the suitability of abstract art in Danish hospital settings and presents findings from two experimental case studies on 98 patients’ well-being in relation to their experience and use of visual art during hospitalization. The case studies employed a mixed-method approach, including interviews and observations informed by thermal video recording, surveys and psychophysiological experiments. Six experiential domains are employed to understand the notion of experience of ‘well-being’: Space, Time, Inter-subjectivity, Body, Mood and Personal identity. The hypothesis that the ambiguity of abstract art leads to stressful effects is not confirmed by the study’s findings. The studies are developed to qualify current guidelines for the application of art, which emphasize a dichotomy between figurative and abstract art. While confirming the positive effects of figurative art, the studies indicate that the ambiguity of meaning in abstract compositions can also facilitate patients’ memories, thoughts and feelings, addressed as experiential domains of well-being.

AB - Within the evidence-based design discourse, and deriving particularly from the theory of emotional congruence, abstract art has been indicated as unsuitable for hospitals. As patients may often experience unfamiliarity, vulnerability, stress, unpredictability and uneasiness in hospitals, these negative factors in terms of patients’ well-being are predicted to be detrimentally reinforced by abstract art, but alleviated by particular forms of figurative art. The present paper focuses particularly on this question of the suitability of abstract art in Danish hospital settings and presents findings from two experimental case studies on 98 patients’ well-being in relation to their experience and use of visual art during hospitalization. The case studies employed a mixed-method approach, including interviews and observations informed by thermal video recording, surveys and psychophysiological experiments. Six experiential domains are employed to understand the notion of experience of ‘well-being’: Space, Time, Inter-subjectivity, Body, Mood and Personal identity. The hypothesis that the ambiguity of abstract art leads to stressful effects is not confirmed by the study’s findings. The studies are developed to qualify current guidelines for the application of art, which emphasize a dichotomy between figurative and abstract art. While confirming the positive effects of figurative art, the studies indicate that the ambiguity of meaning in abstract compositions can also facilitate patients’ memories, thoughts and feelings, addressed as experiential domains of well-being.

KW - health environment

KW - healing arts

KW - well-being

KW - phenomenology

KW - mixed-methods

UR - http://www.arch17.aau.dk/digitalAssets/295/295627_arch17_conference_proceedings.pdf

M3 - Article in proceeding

VL - 1

SP - 105

BT - ARCH17

A2 - Mathiasen, Nanet

A2 - Frandsen, Anne Kathrine

PB - Polyteknisk Boghandel og Forlag

CY - København

ER -

Nielsen SML, Mullins MF. Beyond the dichotomy of figurative and abstract art in hospitals: The potential of visual art as a generator of well-being. In Mathiasen N, Frandsen AK, editors, ARCH17: 3rd international conference on architecture, research, care and health. Conference Proceedings. 1 ed. Vol. 1. København: Polyteknisk Boghandel og Forlag. 2017. p. 105