Abstract

This article critically reflects on the viability of the idea that reforming
engineering education will result in more holistic engineering work practices. Drawing on an empirical study, the article aims to demonstrate that in order to change existing engineering work practices, it might be necessary to change engineers’ knowledge and skills; however, such changes are far from sufficient. Conditions and circumstances external to practitioners’ knowledge and skills are crucial if engineering work is to become more holistic. To illustrate this point, the article outlines an empirical study of a small team of professionals who engage in holistic engineering work practices in an engineering consultancy company. The work practices are investigated using a philosophical empirical method that inquires into the doings, sayings, and relatings of the practitioners. The study describes the practice architecture that shapes and is shaped by the practitioners’ activities, and it demonstrate how the practice landscape prevents enactments of holistic engineering work practices.
Original languageEnglish
JournalEngineering Studies
Volume8
Issue number2
Pages (from-to)140-161
Number of pages21
ISSN1937-8629
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2016

Fingerprint

engineering
Drawing (graphics)
empirical method
Education
engineer
Engineers
Industry
education
Empirical Study

Keywords

  • Engineering work practices
  • engineering reform
  • holistic engineering
  • practice theory

Cite this

@article{a03934be585c4c49838e4b46dcb5ea79,
title = "Ideas of holistic engineering meet engineering work practices",
abstract = "This article critically reflects on the viability of the idea that reformingengineering education will result in more holistic engineering work practices. Drawing on an empirical study, the article aims to demonstrate that in order to change existing engineering work practices, it might be necessary to change engineers’ knowledge and skills; however, such changes are far from sufficient. Conditions and circumstances external to practitioners’ knowledge and skills are crucial if engineering work is to become more holistic. To illustrate this point, the article outlines an empirical study of a small team of professionals who engage in holistic engineering work practices in an engineering consultancy company. The work practices are investigated using a philosophical empirical method that inquires into the doings, sayings, and relatings of the practitioners. The study describes the practice architecture that shapes and is shaped by the practitioners’ activities, and it demonstrate how the practice landscape prevents enactments of holistic engineering work practices.",
keywords = "Engineering work practices, Engineering reform, holistic engineering, Practice theory, Engineering work practices, engineering reform, holistic engineering, practice theory",
author = "Anders Buch",
year = "2016",
doi = "10.1080/19378629.2016.1197227",
language = "English",
volume = "8",
pages = "140--161",
journal = "Engineering Studies",
issn = "1937-8629",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "2",

}

Ideas of holistic engineering meet engineering work practices. / Buch, Anders.

In: Engineering Studies, Vol. 8, No. 2, 2016, p. 140-161.

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Ideas of holistic engineering meet engineering work practices

AU - Buch, Anders

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - This article critically reflects on the viability of the idea that reformingengineering education will result in more holistic engineering work practices. Drawing on an empirical study, the article aims to demonstrate that in order to change existing engineering work practices, it might be necessary to change engineers’ knowledge and skills; however, such changes are far from sufficient. Conditions and circumstances external to practitioners’ knowledge and skills are crucial if engineering work is to become more holistic. To illustrate this point, the article outlines an empirical study of a small team of professionals who engage in holistic engineering work practices in an engineering consultancy company. The work practices are investigated using a philosophical empirical method that inquires into the doings, sayings, and relatings of the practitioners. The study describes the practice architecture that shapes and is shaped by the practitioners’ activities, and it demonstrate how the practice landscape prevents enactments of holistic engineering work practices.

AB - This article critically reflects on the viability of the idea that reformingengineering education will result in more holistic engineering work practices. Drawing on an empirical study, the article aims to demonstrate that in order to change existing engineering work practices, it might be necessary to change engineers’ knowledge and skills; however, such changes are far from sufficient. Conditions and circumstances external to practitioners’ knowledge and skills are crucial if engineering work is to become more holistic. To illustrate this point, the article outlines an empirical study of a small team of professionals who engage in holistic engineering work practices in an engineering consultancy company. The work practices are investigated using a philosophical empirical method that inquires into the doings, sayings, and relatings of the practitioners. The study describes the practice architecture that shapes and is shaped by the practitioners’ activities, and it demonstrate how the practice landscape prevents enactments of holistic engineering work practices.

KW - Engineering work practices

KW - Engineering reform

KW - holistic engineering

KW - Practice theory

KW - Engineering work practices

KW - engineering reform

KW - holistic engineering

KW - practice theory

U2 - 10.1080/19378629.2016.1197227

DO - 10.1080/19378629.2016.1197227

M3 - Journal article

VL - 8

SP - 140

EP - 161

JO - Engineering Studies

JF - Engineering Studies

SN - 1937-8629

IS - 2

ER -