Public Service Media Online, Advertising and the Third-Party User Data Business: A Trade versus Trust Dilemma?

Jannick Kirk Sørensen, Hilde van den Bulck

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

News and media webpages generate valuable consumer data, collected by third-party servers. Via longitudinal experiment this paper shows that also in 35 cases of European public service media (PSM) websites from 19 countries, third party servers are active. This does not only constitute a pressing privacy problem in relation to GDPR but it also challenges the notion of PSM organisations as particularly trusted providers of media content. This has implications for their role and placement in the commercial media landscape as well as for their independency, but also for their survival in the future media landscape. Our analysis shows not only connections between the presence of advertisement and the number of third party servers found, but also a reflection of the different types of European media systems. To provide a benchmark for our analysis, 64 private media websites has also analysed for the presence of third-party servers. The empirical results creates a pressing need for discussions on whether or how PSM organisations participate in the commercial web ecology of user data exchange and utilisation, e.g. for the purposes of user profiling, targeting and PSM performance measurement.
Original languageEnglish
JournalConvergence. The International Journal of Research into New Media Technologies
ISSN1354-8565
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 2019

Fingerprint

online media
public service
Marketing
Servers
Websites
Industry
Electronic data interchange
Ecology
website
Public Services
media system
data exchange
performance measurement
privacy
ecology
Experiments
news
utilization

Keywords

  • Public Service Media
  • privacy
  • trust
  • web privacy measurement
  • third-party sites
  • Media Policy
  • public service broadcasting
  • GDPR
  • General data protection regulation

Cite this

@article{6012086567624e2e8bc11dd6ff4af45d,
title = "Public Service Media Online, Advertising and the Third-Party User Data Business: A Trade versus Trust Dilemma?",
abstract = "News and media webpages generate valuable consumer data, collected by third-party servers. Via longitudinal experiment this paper shows that also in 35 cases of European public service media (PSM) websites from 19 countries, third party servers are active. This does not only constitute a pressing privacy problem in relation to GDPR but it also challenges the notion of PSM organisations as particularly trusted providers of media content. This has implications for their role and placement in the commercial media landscape as well as for their independency, but also for their survival in the future media landscape. Our analysis shows not only connections between the presence of advertisement and the number of third party servers found, but also a reflection of the different types of European media systems. To provide a benchmark for our analysis, 64 private media websites has also analysed for the presence of third-party servers. The empirical results creates a pressing need for discussions on whether or how PSM organisations participate in the commercial web ecology of user data exchange and utilisation, e.g. for the purposes of user profiling, targeting and PSM performance measurement.",
keywords = "Public Service Media, privacy, trust, web privacy measurement, third-party sites, Media Policy, public service broadcasting, GDPR, General data protection regulation",
author = "S{\o}rensen, {Jannick Kirk} and {van den Bulck}, Hilde",
year = "2019",
doi = "10.1177/1354856518790203",
language = "English",
journal = "Convergence: The International Journal of Research into New Media Technologies",
issn = "1354-8565",
publisher = "Sage Journals",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Public Service Media Online, Advertising and the Third-Party User Data Business

T2 - A Trade versus Trust Dilemma?

AU - Sørensen, Jannick Kirk

AU - van den Bulck, Hilde

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - News and media webpages generate valuable consumer data, collected by third-party servers. Via longitudinal experiment this paper shows that also in 35 cases of European public service media (PSM) websites from 19 countries, third party servers are active. This does not only constitute a pressing privacy problem in relation to GDPR but it also challenges the notion of PSM organisations as particularly trusted providers of media content. This has implications for their role and placement in the commercial media landscape as well as for their independency, but also for their survival in the future media landscape. Our analysis shows not only connections between the presence of advertisement and the number of third party servers found, but also a reflection of the different types of European media systems. To provide a benchmark for our analysis, 64 private media websites has also analysed for the presence of third-party servers. The empirical results creates a pressing need for discussions on whether or how PSM organisations participate in the commercial web ecology of user data exchange and utilisation, e.g. for the purposes of user profiling, targeting and PSM performance measurement.

AB - News and media webpages generate valuable consumer data, collected by third-party servers. Via longitudinal experiment this paper shows that also in 35 cases of European public service media (PSM) websites from 19 countries, third party servers are active. This does not only constitute a pressing privacy problem in relation to GDPR but it also challenges the notion of PSM organisations as particularly trusted providers of media content. This has implications for their role and placement in the commercial media landscape as well as for their independency, but also for their survival in the future media landscape. Our analysis shows not only connections between the presence of advertisement and the number of third party servers found, but also a reflection of the different types of European media systems. To provide a benchmark for our analysis, 64 private media websites has also analysed for the presence of third-party servers. The empirical results creates a pressing need for discussions on whether or how PSM organisations participate in the commercial web ecology of user data exchange and utilisation, e.g. for the purposes of user profiling, targeting and PSM performance measurement.

KW - Public Service Media

KW - privacy

KW - trust

KW - web privacy measurement

KW - third-party sites

KW - Media Policy

KW - public service broadcasting

KW - GDPR

KW - General data protection regulation

U2 - 10.1177/1354856518790203

DO - 10.1177/1354856518790203

M3 - Journal article

JO - Convergence: The International Journal of Research into New Media Technologies

JF - Convergence: The International Journal of Research into New Media Technologies

SN - 1354-8565

ER -